Heat pump vs. oil: why efficiency matters
Many Atlantic Canadians have heard that heat pumps can lower their energy costs. But comparing electricity and oil prices alone doesn't tell the whole story. Understanding the difference starts with understanding efficiency.
Why this question matters
Energy costs are a major concern across Atlantic Canada.
For many households that rely on heating oil, staying warm throughout the winter can be one of the largest energy expenses of the year. At the same time, more homeowners are considering heat pumps as a way to improve comfort and reduce their dependence on fossil fuels. The key question is simple:
Can a heat pump save you money compared to heating with oil?
The answer depends on your home, your heating system, and energy prices in your area. But understanding the comparison starts with understanding how these different technologies use energy.
The important difference: efficiency
An oil furnace creates heat by burning fuel.
Instead of generating heat by burning fuel, a heat pump moves existing heat from outdoors into your home. Because moving heat is more efficient than creating it, heat pumps can often heat a home using much less energy than traditional oil systems.
Because of this, comparing the price of oil to the price of electricity doesn’t provide the full financial picture. The real comparison is how much useful heat you receive in your house for each dollar that you spend.
What Atlantic Canadians pay today
Electricity rates vary across the region, but Atlantic Canadians generally pay between 14 and 19 cents per kilowatt-hour for residential electricity:
- Newfoundland and Labrador: approximately 14.6¢/kWh
- New Brunswick: approximately 15.8¢/kWh
- Prince Edward Island: approximately 17.8¢/kWh
- Nova Scotia: approximately 19.1¢/kWh
Home heating oil prices fluctuate throughout the year and can vary significantly from one province to another. For some context, Natural Resources Canada reported an average Canadian furnace oil price of approximately $2.47 per litre as of October 2026.
At first glance, comparing 14 to 19 cents per kilowatt-hour with $2.47 per litre may seem straightforward. But because heat pumps and oil furnaces deliver heat differently, the efficiency of each system matters just as much as the price of the energy it uses.
A simple example
Imagine a home that needs heat over the winter.
An oil heating system converts most, but not all, of the energy in fuel into heat for your home.
A cold-climate heat pump can provide two to three times more heat than the electricity it consumes, depending on weather conditions and the exact system installed.
This means that a heat pump doesn’t need electricity to be cheaper than oil. The efficiency of the system changes the equation.
Because heat pumps use energy differently, many households can meet the same heating needs while using less energy than an oil heating system.
Savings can vary
No two homes are exactly the same.
The actual costs depend on several factors, including:
- Home size
- Home insulation
- Temperature settings
- Local electricity and heating oil prices
- Weather conditions
This means that there isn’t a single savings number that will apply to everyone. Real savings depend on the location, and how a specific home uses energy.
Stability matters too
Cost isn't just about today's bill.
Heating oil prices are tied to global fuel markets and can rise or fall significantly from one season to the next.
Electricity prices also change, but electrification allows households to rely more on energy produced within the region, including hydro, wind, solar, and other electricity sources.
For many households, the appeal of a heat pump isn't only the possibility of lower operating costs. It's also greater control over future energy expenses, improved comfort, and reduced exposure to volatile fuel prices.
What should homeowners do?
If you are currently using oil and considering a heat pump, focus on your own numbers.
Take a look at:
- Your annual oil consumption
- Recent electricity bills and rates
- Available rebates and incentives
- Whether your home is suited to a heat pump
Chat with a qualified installer. They can help you with estimating expected costs based on your current household energy use.
The best decision is an informed decision.